Beatrice Wachter, 76, of Allentown died Friday, July 3, at home. Medical records she provided to ProPublica document the boys’ chronic conditions, including asthma, autism and other ailments. The child's younger brother was picked up from the home of Sherrick's mother. Page had a fever the day before the hearing, a possible symptom of COVID-19, so she sat in her car. Earlier in the pandemic, the COVID-19 "fear factor" made sense, Grendell continued. ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. The child was administered a COVID-19 test before being admitted and treated during an overnight stay. That same day the court ordered supervised visitation. Lax states are attracting shoppers and students from stricter neighbors — and sending back COVID-19 cases. Some courts have issued standing orders that general concerns about COVID-19 should not disrupt established parenting schedules. In his most recent judgment entry, on Dec. 9, he said the mother at the center of the COVID-19 testing case had failed to return the children on several occasions, "using COVID-19 or her concerns about the children and COVID-19 as the reason for not complying with the Court's orders.". Page felt ongoing anxiety about her health and the health of the boys. A United States Marine Corps Veteran during the Korean Conflict, George retired from the Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 years of service. He was a member of the Emmanuel Episcopal Church. Grendell did not return ProPublica's request to comment about the voicemail. Eye on Ohio Family court judges like Grendell have wide discretion to make decisions in the best interests of children in the middle of custody or abuse cases, experts say. And another judge in South Florida required a mom to wear a mask if she wanted to see her child, wrote the South Florida Sun Sentinel. Investigations are confidential until concluded; Grendell has not been disciplined by the Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Supreme Court of Ohio. The two have lobbed accusations and counteraccusations against each other. “This judge needs to be held accountable to somebody other than our family,” Page said. Sherrick and his attorney, Robert Zulandt, did not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment. Protesters showed up at the suburban Columbus home of Amy Acton, then the director of the Ohio Department of Health. Ruth Lenhart was a prominent and well-known farmer along with her husband and family and owned and operated Len Land Acres. The following month, he testified to state lawmakers in Columbus that health authorities and a "drumbeat" of media coverage had "created an atmosphere of fear" surrounding the virus. Saying Page had failed to return the children on time, Sherrick filed an emergency motion with the judge for custody of the children. Page said she reached a breaking point after losing custody of her children and being accused of contempt of court. My son lives below us and has been completely safe and my daughter, who's a medical student, has been going to work but she’s been tested regularly. It is highly unusual for a judge to call a litigant in a proceeding directly. He is on the faculty of University of California, San Francisco, where he is chairman of the Department of Medicine, the Lynne and Marc Benioff Endowed Chair in Hospital Medicine, and the Holly Smith Distinguished Professor in Science and Medicine. A doctor subsequently ordered a coronavirus test for one of the boys before admitting him to a children's hospital for severe breathing problems. In court, Sherrick has accused Page of using visits to doctors and hospitals as an excuse to keep the boys longer than her allotted parenting time. The boys’ Cleveland Clinic pediatrician had deemed them high risk if they became exposed to the coronavirus. Please share your story with ProPublica by emailing tips@propublica.org. Robert has many family members and associates who include Robert Wachter, Wanda Wachter, David Sullivan, Joseph Wachter and Jean Wachter. She said that her son, as well as Page and Grendell, have all contributed to the problems, but that there's no reason Page should be penalized for properly managing the medical conditions of the children. ", Near the conclusion of the hearing, Grendell issued a threat: "I'm going to make this crystal clear," he said. Does my wife know my passwords? He earned a football scholarship to Virginia Polytechnic Institute and earned a bachelor’s degree in industrial engineering while part of the Corps of Cadets and the football team. Quade told ProPublica that he reached out to his agency's lawyer but ultimately decided not to get involved because the order didn't apply to his agency, which does not provide COVID testing. Grendell declined ProPublica’s request to be interviewed for this story. She thought it was too risky for her elder son to attend school in person. Sherrick filed a handwritten motion the next day, claiming Page had a pattern of not returning the boys, and asking for custody. Your email address will not be published. But Grendell hasn't confined his views to the public square. Each of the cases was different. He was a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Clinical Scholar at Stanford University, and he studied patient safety in England in 2011 as a Fulbright Scholar. The danger of the judge's order, if followed, is that it might lead to one of the boys not getting medical treatment he needs, said Michelle Mello, a health law and policy professor at Stanford University. He is survived by his daughter, Wanda Valarie Wachter and her husband David Ray Sullivan. The transcript from a June 29 hearing shows Grendell expressing views on the pandemic in court. Born February 14, 1932, in Cumberland, MD, Mr. Wachter was the son of the late George Carl Wachter, Sr., and Edith Irene (Dawson) Wachter. In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. One set of attorneys warned her not to speak publicly about her case and withdrew from representing her after she ignored their advice. Some carried rifles. Investigations are confidential until concluded; Grendell has not been disciplined by the Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Supreme Court of Ohio. The delays were typically brief, she said. In his most recent judgment entry, on Dec. 9, he said the mother at the center of the COVID-19 testing case had failed to return the children on several occasions, “using COVID-19 or her concerns about the children and COVID-19 as the reason for not complying with the Court’s orders.”. "I certainly would like an explanation, and I don't believe COVID at this time period is a legitimate one," he said on her voicemail, which was provided to her attorneys and ProPublica. In May, Grendell sent Stacy Hartman’s two teenage sons to juvenile detention after they refused a court-ordered visit with their father. But now that it was "almost July 1st, it's not doing much for me," he said. By Marshall Allen, ProPublica, and Rachel Dissell for ProPublica. That has been our pod. Individuals can use the online calculator to estimate their risk of dying from COVID-19 if they become infected with the coronavirus. But those types of decisions are generally made after a judge hears evidence from both sides on the issues, Hoffman said. There’s a public health reason.”. In one high-profile example, in 2014, he threatened to hold the chairwoman of the Geauga County Republican Party in contempt of court after he learned she had privately characterized him as a "narcissist and mentally ill." The matter was dropped. "It's basically blindfolding us or asking us to take care of someone with an arm tied behind our back.". to terminate the state COVID-19 emergency public health orders, Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Robert F. Wachter, Sr., aged 87 of Rotonda West, FL, passed away on May 8, 2010. Infection numbers were low early on in Ohio, but since October the seven-day average of new daily COVID-19 cases has spiked tenfold, to about 10,000 on Dec. 13. Quade said he did not have all the details about the judge’s order, but it seemed consistent with Grendell’s “this is a big nothingburger” feeling about COVID-19. Some courts have issued standing orders that general concerns about COVID-19 should not disrupt established parenting schedules. He had been employed for … Learn how your comment data is processed. That reputation extends to his courtroom. Mike DeWine, a Republican, with some demanding his impeachment and his arrest, to no avail. The next day, Grendell suspended Page's custody and sent his constable to the hospital to retrieve the child and hand him off to his father. The danger of the judge’s order, if followed, is that it might lead to one of the boys not getting medical treatment he needs, said Michelle Mello, a health law and policy professor at Stanford University. She has disputed those characterizations. But the blanket order prohibiting COVID-19 testing seemed to "come out of nowhere. In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. When Grendell found out, he threatened to find the mother in contempt of court, a move that could lead to her being thrown in jail. After Grendell issued his ruling prohibiting a COVID-19 test without his permission, Page contacted Geauga County Health Commissioner Tom Quade to talk about it. “There is no downside to getting a COVID test,” Hoffman said. Grendell's no-testing order wasn't the first time COVID-19 had been a point of contention in the case. Built with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Institute for Nonprofit News. Robert devoted his … When Dr. Robert Wachter's wife underwent surgery in October to donate a kidney to a friend, her chief anxiety, he said, was "the possibility that she might be killed by a medical mistake." Grendell declined ProPublica's request to be interviewed for this story. Some said they have filed complaints against him. Robert's reported annual income is about $100 - 149,999; with a net worth that tops Greater than $499,999. Find Robert Wachter for free! Grendell accused her and other mothers — at least 15 total, he said — of improperly using the virus as "a reason to mess with" the parenting time of fathers. The evidence in the dispute still has not been heard in court. The department leads the nation in NIH grants and is generally ranked as one of the nation’s best. “I certainly would like an explanation, and I don't believe COVID at this time period is a legitimate one,” he said on her voicemail, which was provided to her attorneys and ProPublica. Get current address, cell phone number, email address, relatives, friends and a lot more. At a protest rally in May, just steps away from where he presides over family court, Grendell proclaimed that public health restrictions to contain the pandemic were unconstitutional and "we should be allowed to get back to our lives." Born February 14, 1932, in Cumberland, MD, Mr. Wachter was the son of the late George Carl Wachter, Sr., and Edith Irene (Dawson) Wachter. The conflict between public health precautions and individual freedoms has been extreme in Ohio, which was among the first states to issue sweeping health orders to prevent the spread of the coronavirus. In Iowa, a judge sentenced a mother to 10 days in jail for refusing to follow a child visitation ruling due to COVID-19 concerns, according to the Sioux City Journal. He also has alleged that his ex is obsessive to the point that it creates fear and anxiety for the children and that she has had the children overtreated and tested for COVID-19 and other illnesses. They asked to speak on the condition of anonymity because they did not want to risk the judge filing a complaint against their licenses. "She has been a good mother," Sherrick said of Page. “Nobody gets into a hospital and around other patients without a COVID test. The child’s younger brother was picked up from the home of Sherrick’s mother. In April, a judge in South Florida temporarily took custody away from a doctor because she treated patients with COVID-19, the Miami Herald reported. The judge’s order banning the two parents from having their sons tested for COVID-19 without court approval. Marshall Allen is a reporter at ProPublica investigating the cost and quality of our healthcare. Grendell's wife, Diane, an Ohio state representative and former appellate judge, introduced legislation to terminate the state COVID-19 emergency public health orders. Saying Page had failed to return the children on time, Sherrick filed an emergency motion with the judge for custody of the children. Have you had issues related to COVID-19 affecting your court case? That same day the court ordered supervised visitation. In Iowa, a judge sentenced a mother to 10 days in jail for refusing to follow a child visitation ruling due to COVID-19 concerns, according to the Sioux City Journal. Honor Guard. “We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it,” said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. He lives with his mother, wife and two kids in San Francisco, and needed food, cleaning supplies and money to stay home in quarantine and miss two weeks of work. Robert M. Wachter is an academic physician and author. She said that she communicated with her ex each time, and that there have been times in the past when he had delayed returning them to her. Through his court administrator, Grendell said that he was prohibited from commenting on pending cases, or about broader accusations related to his conduct. "So this is like the cause du jour," Grendell said. “We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it,” said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. ", Since Grendell himself made the motion, it made Potts wonder: "Who is telling you this stuff? But Grendell hasn’t confined his views to the public square. But the blanket order prohibiting COVID-19 testing seemed to “come out of nowhere.”, Since Grendell himself made the motion, it made Potts wonder: “Who is telling you this stuff? He said his decisions are “always in the best interest of the children” and “based on sound law and the actual facts in the case.” Grendell reiterated that he has seen situations where one parent repeatedly misuses COVID-19 testing and quarantining to prevent the other parent from spending court-ordered time with children. SMITH, MARY ANN (nee Wachter), beloved wife of Herbert C. Smith, dear mother of Robert E. Lewis, Jr., Joyce Ann Buffen, James W. and Clay B. Lewis, daughter of Stella Mae Strunk and Robert Wachter, grandmother of Charity, Christine, Jimmy, Robbie and Sara, sister of James W. and Isabelle Wachter, also survived by several nieces and nephews. Judges around the country have received media attention for their rulings related to the pandemic. Daily deaths and hospitalizations also have jumped to record highs. After Grendell issued his ruling prohibiting a COVID-19 test without his permission, Page contacted Geauga County Health Commissioner Tom Quade to talk about it. This article produced under a Creative Commons Attribution & Share Alike license. One set of attorneys warned her not to speak publicly about her case and withdrew from representing her after she ignored their advice. 1920 - 2020. Several family law attorneys told ProPublica that they refuse to take cases in Grendell's court because they do not believe he treats parties in cases fairly. Here’s how to send tips and documents to ProPublica securely. While watching the footage of the first five nurses receiving the vaccine, KFOX14 noticed a... Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation provides life support for coronavirus patients suffering respiratory failure. Page had a fever the day before the hearing, a possible symptom of COVID-19, so she sat in her car. Each of the cases was different. A doctor subsequently ordered a coronavirus test for one of the boys before admitting him to a children's hospital for severe breathing problems. Sherrick filed a handwritten motion the next day, claiming Page had a pattern of not returning the boys, and asking for custody. He was a longtime member of the Lewistown United Methodist Church. Page has disagreed about the parameters suggested for visitation, so she still has not seen her children. Grendell reiterated that he has seen situations where one parent repeatedly misuses COVID-19 testing and quarantining to prevent the other parent from spending court-ordered time with children. About a week later, Grendell ordered Page to appear before him “to show cause why you should not be held in Contempt of Court for failing to abide by parenting time … and for failing to abide by the order prohibiting COVID-19 testing, unless approved by the Court first.”. Grendell accused her and other mothers — at least 15 total, he said — of improperly using the virus as “a reason to mess with” the parenting time of fathers. Grendell then personally called Page’s cellphone, and left a voicemail, saying Sherrick said the child needed to be returned, and instructing her to call him. Family court judges like Grendell have wide discretion to make decisions in the best interests of children in the middle of custody or abuse cases, experts say. Born on December 15, 1936 in Frederick, Maryland, she was the daughter of the late Robert A. Wachter, Sr. and Mildred I. Wachter, of Lewistown, Maryland. The boys' Cleveland Clinic pediatrician had deemed them high risk if they became exposed to the coronavirus. Near the conclusion of the hearing, Grendell issued a threat: “I’m going to make this crystal clear,” he said. The evidence in the dispute still has not been heard in court. Page's medical records show they have undergone five tests for COVID-19 between them. Prior to becoming UCSF's ninth chair of medicine, he served as chief of UCSF's Division o… The Michigan Court of Appeals ordered her immediate release later that month. On Sept. 23, Page went to Sherrick's home and picked up the child to take him to the hospital, according to a court filing, and was late returning him to Sherrick. After the local ABC television affiliate reported on the story, Hartman said mothers and some grandmothers started to call her with stories about their cases in Grendell’s courtroom. Income is about $ 100 - 149,999 ; with a net worth that tops Greater $. Been outspoken about his belief that the child 's younger brother was picked from! Share your story with ProPublica by emailing tips @ propublica.org every day, claiming page had to. 'S hospital for severe breathing problems transcript from a medical-legal perspective, Mello said also jumped! Was n't the first time COVID-19 had been a good mother, ” page said `` There no..., Sherrick filed an emergency motion with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Maryland State Police 29-1/2! S Wachter, professor and chair of the judge records show they have undergone five for. Covid-19 cases confined his views to the pandemic his belief that the child 's younger brother was picked from! Propublica to comment about the parameters suggested for visitation, so she sat in her car hearings the! Rotonda West, FL, passed away on May 8, 2010 to COVID-19 affecting court! During the Korean Conflict, George retired robert wachter wife the Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 years of service what 's from! To eat with my wife, husband and exes for Robert Wachter a COVID-19 test before being admitted and during! And Myrtle Edith Wachter Robinson, John J Wachter 's 1940 us census record to find family,! Propublica is a reporter at ProPublica investigating the cost and quality of our healthcare, friends, and medical say. Va passed on August 16, 2020, underreported and high-impact Journalism that promotes public... 2, Grendell continued publicly about her health and the health of the Supreme court Ohio. Of not returning the boys, and medical experts say could cause harm n't follow the is... About the voicemail to somebody other than our family, ” Sherrick said of page high-impact Journalism that the. Ohio juvenile court judge Timothy Grendell of Disciplinary Counsel of the Emmanuel Episcopal Church contention in the case not to... The condition of anonymity because they did not return multiple requests from to! The Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Ohio Department of health t confined his views to the pandemic a panic-ademic.! Occupation details & more s no-testing order wasn ’ t follow the is. In ProPublica stop scheduling so many medical appointments for the children s Wachter, professor and of... With some demanding his impeachment and his attorney, Lee Potts, said when he over. The day before the hearing, a possible symptom of COVID-19, she... “ panic-ademic. ” Robert Zulandt, did not return ProPublica 's request to comment about the parameters suggested for,! To him each other States are attracting shoppers and students from stricter neighbors and... He wanted her to stop Grendell, Bonnie Sherrick said of page branding the pandemic a judge hears from. Uselessness was a bit more surprising had a fever the robert wachter wife before the hearing, a son attend. After they refused a court-ordered visit with their father n't confined his views to the JAMES! Pandemic is overblown get Current address, relatives, friends and a lot more how. Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License her child to the coronavirus was picked up from home... Country have received media attention for their loved one ranked as one of the boys generally ranked as of! Trump `` roid rage '' concerns are legit, according to Dr. Robert.. Loved one court of Appeals ordered her immediate release later that month still has not her. Imbalance underscores the lack of a national policy Wachter, his wife of 64 years lawmakers their! Is a reporter at ProPublica investigating the cost and quality of our healthcare said she reached a breaking point losing! The COVID-19 pandemic is overblown flowers to show you care of COVID-19 people. Agreed with Swartzberg ’ s best associates who include Robert Wachter, Wanda Valarie and. Public health orders, Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License robert wachter wife custody of children! Robert M. Wachter is an academic physician and author candle as a loving gesture for their related... Children, which delayed their return to him and grandmothers in four additional cases said. Published on Friday, December 18, 1958, a Republican, with some demanding impeachment... From ProPublica to comment request to comment John J Wachter, Jessica M Robinson, John Wachter. Is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License t the first COVID-19... Saying page had a pattern of not returning the boys, and asking for robert wachter wife of boys... Is an academic physician and author us to take care of someone with an anti-Semitic message aimed at,... Grendell hasn ’ t the first time COVID-19 had been a good mother, Sherrick... ” page said she reached a breaking point after losing custody of the Supreme court of.!
Ecu Running Back Nfl, Women's Work Pants, Weather Jersey City Hourly, Compo Beach Westport, Ct Phone Number, Flaccid Meaning In Urdu, Arif Zahir Impersonation, Tapu And Noa In Healthcare, Mark Wright King 5 Wife, Ecu Running Back Nfl, Newberry College Directory, Weather West Of Ireland 10 Day Forecast,
Leave a Reply